Date range

Exclusion of expert’s video simulation, because its probative value was substantially outweighed by the possibility of unfair prejudice, is not an abuse of discretion because the simulation could have caused jury to improperly defer to expert’s opinion.

In this automobile accident case, the Fourth District Court held that a trial court’s exclusion of a video simulation—because its probative value was substantially outweighed by the possibility of unfair prejudice—was not

In order for an expert’s testimony on permanency to be impeached, or otherwise rebutted, the jury’s ability to reject the testimony must be based on some reasonable basis in the evidence.

The defendants in this automobile negligence case appealed an order granting the plaintiff a new trial on the issue of damages after the trial court directed a verdict on the issue of permanency regarding one of the claimed injuries.