Victory Obtained at Trial in Case Involving Negligent Sidewalk Design

We won a premises liability case involving allegations of negligent sidewalk design. The plaintiff, a quadriplegic who has been in a wheelchair since 1984, entered our client’s convenience store using the designated wheelchair ramp without issue. However, upon leaving the store, he inexplicably failed to use the same ramp and, instead, attempted to go directly over the curb, resulting in a fall and a fractured leg. During his deposition, the plaintiff admitted he successfully navigated the wheelchair ramp upon entering the store. He also acknowledged seeing and knowing the ramp was there but did not use it upon exiting, in addition to confirming there were no defects in the sidewalk or curb. He admitted that raised sidewalks in front of stores are common, particularly at gas stations, and conceded that nothing obstructed his view of the curb or ramp. At the hearing, we countered the plaintiff’s last-minute attempt to introduce new testimony claiming that he was discouraged from using the sidewalk due to merchandise being present and that the store should have used a color to distinguish the curb from the parking lot. The judge requested competing orders and ultimately agreed with our application of the law, granting our motion.