Trucking and transportation is one of the oldest practice areas at Marshall Dennehey. Our group handles cases in the state and federal courts of Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, Ohio, Florida, New York and Connecticut. The Trucking & Transportation Practice represents clients and their carriers in complex tort and coverage litigation involving all types of common and private carriers. The members of this group include shareholders and associates who have handled cases for large common carrier transportation fleets engaged in interstate trucking, railroads, waste hauling, taxicab, shuttle and bus operators, rental vehicle fleets and ambulance services. These attorneys have represented insurers and self-insureds in personal injury, cargo, environmental, hazardous materials, indemnification and insurance coverage issues, and are keenly aware of the impact of the sophisticated issues and interrelationships of the parties.
Staged Trucking Accidents: A Growing Threat
Staged accidents have become a serious concern in the trucking and transportation industry. These deliberate collisions are orchestrated as part of elaborate insurance scams, with individuals seeking substantial payouts through false claims. These schemes can result in significant financial losses and legal challenges for trucking companies.
Our skilled defense attorneys help organizations combat staged accident fraud by providing early fraud detection guidance, preserving key evidence, and developing strategies to expose fraudulent claims. We work with state and federal authorities as well as the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) to ensure that claims are appropriately referred to the proper authorities for potential restitution. In certain circumstances, we offer pre-suit solutions to stop litigation before it begins—saving legal and indemnity spend. When litigation arises, we provide a vigorous defense to protect our clients' financial stability and reputation. Our attorneys have several decades of experience in this space to effectively and comprehensively combat this growing threat.
From the inception of our firm, we have handled complex litigation involving the shipping of goods over waterways, highways and rail. With today's emphasis on the proper handling of hazardous materials during shipment, many of our transportation attorneys have also cross-trained in environmental and toxic tort matters. In addition, we have the full support of our appellate and toxic tort environmental sections to draw upon in the handling of any transportation matter.
In conjunction with the firm's Insurance Coverage/Bad Faith and Appellate Advocacy and Post-Trial practice groups, we represent insurance carriers in coverage matters that arise from underlying transportation cases.
The members of the Trucking & Transportation Practice are active participants in a number of the major transportation law organizations including the Trucking Industry Defense Association, ATA Litigation Center, ABA Transportation Megaconferences, RIMS, Defense Research Institute and Association of Transportation Practitioners.
We are aware of today's focus on securing sound legal services at reasonable fee levels. Our firm has grown because of our sensitivity in this area. This is especially true in the transportation industry where many of our clients have large, self-insured retentions that necessitate close control of legal costs and expenses. Our trial lawyers take a practical, results-oriented approach to their cases. The firm maintains competitive rates through task-appropriate delegation which is consistent with the overall close supervision and client responsiveness required in transportation matters. We are willing to discuss, develop and implement alternative billing formats wherever possible.
Results
Defense Verdict Returned After Short Jury Deliberation in High-Exposure New Jersey Trucking Case
Christopher Block and Paul Lanza (both of Roseland) successfully obtained a defense verdict in a trucking accident in New Jersey. The plaintiff claimed that our client merged into her lane at the George Washington Bridge toll plaza causing her to sustain neck and back injuries for which she underwent two spinal surgeries. Our client testified that both of their lanes ended and, because they were required to merge, he had the right-of-way since the front of his truck was ahead of the front of her vehicle. Our accident reconstruction expert confirmed that our driver had the right-of-way and opined that plaintiff was the sole cause of the accident. We also disputed the causation of plaintiff’s alleged injuries based on the very limited property damage to her vehicle, as well as the fact that she had prior, similar injuries. After a little more than an hour of deliberations, the jury returned a verdict finding that our driver was not negligent. The trial team was assisted by associate attorney Haleigh Catalano and paralegal Kelly Dermody who provided critical support with motions in limine and trial management.
Trial Court’s Denial of Motions Reversed Before the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
We convinced the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania to reverse the trial court’s denial of motions for post-trial relief and to direct entry of judgment notwithstanding the verdict in favor of our client. The plaintiff was injured while standing unsupported on a moving bus. He lost his balance when the bus accelerated away from a bus stop, grabbed an overhead bar to keep from falling, and injured his arm. The video showed that only the plaintiff lost his balance when the bus started moving. At trial, our client moved for nonsuit and directed verdict, arguing the evidence was insufficient to overcome the jerk-and-jolt doctrine that applies when a passenger is injured on a moving bus. To merit the submission of a jerk-and-jolt case to the jury, a plaintiff must establish a sudden stop or jerk so unusual and extraordinary as to be beyond a passenger’s reasonable anticipation. The Honorable James Crumlish denied the motions for nonsuit and directed verdict and also denied our client’s motions for post-trial relief. Judge Crumlish determined the video evidence presented a jury question under the jerk-and-jolt doctrine and mirrored the plaintiff’s counsel’s characterization of the video evidence in doing so. The Commonwealth Court disagreed. After independently reviewing the video evidence, the Commonwealth Court reversed the trial court and granted judgment notwithstanding the verdict to our client. In doing so, it pointed out that various observations of the trial court “were not supported by the video or testimony.”
Thought Leadership
Case Law Alerts
Virginia Federal Court Blocks U.S. DOT’s Attempt to Obtain 17 Million Commercial Driver Records from the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators
November 3, 2026
On August 13, 2026, in the Eastern District of Virginia, two coalitions of attorneys general from more than twenty states and the District of Columbia filed lawsuits seeking Temporary Restraining Orders against the the U.S. DOT, the Department of Homeland Security, and the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration to stop the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators (AAMVA) from turning over more than seventeen million commercial driver records. The AAMVA maintains the Commercial Driver’s License Information System (CDLIS) pursuant to its contract with the U.S. DOT. This system ensures that commercial driver’s license applicants only hold one driver’s license and possess only one complete driving record, which prevents the issuance of commercial driver’s licenses to applicants who have a recorded history of unsafe driving. The demand from the U.S. DOT sought the name, date of birth, state of record, license number, and Social Security Number for every driver in the CDLIS database for five years, as well as the date the Social Security Number was removed from the record if any record previously listed, but no longer had, a Social Security Number attached. Plaintiff states argue that the request violated privacy laws, while the federal government asserts that it is entitled to the records pursuant to the contract between the U.S. DOT and the AAMVA. The Court issued a Temporary Restraining Order on August 21, 2026. On September 17, 2026, the Court granted a preliminary injunction blocking the provision of the AAMVA records and ordered that the federal government is not permitted to take any adverse actions against the AAMVA, including previously threatened cancellation of grants and even the contract with the AAMVA to maintain the CDLIS. At present, without further action, the federal government does not and cannot have access to the AAMVA records sought.
Case Law Alerts
UPDATE: Supreme Court Issues Decision Exposing Freight Brokers to Liability For Negligent Hiring
November 3, 2026
In May 2026, with a unanimous 9-0 decision, the Supreme Court determined that the statutory protections provided by the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (FAAAA) did not bar state law claims against freight brokers for negligent hiring. The FAAAA expressly preempts state regulations affecting prices, routes, and various services provided by freight carriers and brokers. However, the decision notes that the FAAAA contains a specific carveout which permits such state law claims. Specifically, the FAAAA provides for the states to preserve their own safety regulatory authority regarding motor vehicles. The Supreme Court interpreted this language to mean that while states did not have the authority to interfere with business operations of freight carriers and brokers, carrier selection by a broker is not a matter of business operations. Rather, the states have the authority to regulate roadway safety, and negligent hiring falls squarely within the state’s authority.