Roseland
The Roseland, New Jersey, office of Marshall Dennehey opened in February of 1993. Since that time, it has realized substantial growth in response to client demand for our professional services. Roseland is in Essex County, home to Newark, New Jersey's largest city, and is within 30 minutes of New York City. The office services the densely populated counties of the northern part of the state. The attorneys practicing in our Roseland office have easy access to all of the federal and state courts of Northern New Jersey, which counties include Bergen, Essex, Hudson, Hunterdon, Middlesex, Monmouth, Morris, Passaic, Somerset, Sussex, Union and Warren.
Our Roseland office, like all of the firm's offices, provides the advantages of the personal attention of a small firm with the advantages that come from the intellectual property and broad-based experience of a large firm. The office is staffed by native and long-time residents of New Jersey who handle professional liability, product liability, employment, property and casualty, and workers' compensation defense litigation.
Thought Leadership
Case Law Alerts
Essex County Court Dismisses All Claims Against Theft Investigation Firm with Prejudice
November 3, 2026
In this matter, plaintiff filed a complaint against our client, North East Technical Services, Inc. (“NETS”) and other defendants, stemming from the alleged theft of her 2020 Hyundai Santa Fe. Plaintiff alleged her vehicle was stolen from her driveway. The Jersey City Police Department reported the theft to Bloomfield Police Department. Thereafter, the vehicle was impounded at the Jersey City Department of Public Works. NETS was retained by defendant, Progressive Garden State Insurance (“Progressive”) to perform a theft examination. NETS did so, concluding that the vehicle’s ignition lock assembly was intact and not defeated, and that it had last been operated by a key of the proper type, such as the keys present in the vehicle at the time of the examination. Plaintiff’s complaint alleges that NETS willfully and falsely stated the keys were in the vehicle at the time of the investigation because Plaintiff had mailed the keys to Progressive for the theft investigation. Plaintiff further alleges that NETS’ negligent, reckless, and careless acts or omissions in conducting its investigation and reporting their findings to Progressive were to Plaintiff’s detriment. The complaint asserts claims against NETS for conversion (Count Three); unjust enrichment (Count Fourt); violation of the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act (Count Five); and negligence (Count Ten). A motion to dismiss was filed on behalf of NETS wherein it was argued that the complaint fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted because the allegations are either legally insufficient or factually unsupported, and that plaintiff has not established the necessary elements for her claims. NETS further asserts that it is not liable under the theories advanced by Plaintiff, and that the Complaint should be dismissed as a matter of law. With respect to the negligence claim, it was argued that NETS owed no legal duty to plaintiff. As to the conversion claim, it was argued that Plaintiff’s conversion claim is deficient because the complaint does not allege any facts showing that NETS wrongfully exercised dominion or control over her property. As to the unjust enrichment claim is legally deficient because plaintiff has failed to allege a sufficient basis to establish that NETS received any benefit other than payment for services rendered to Progressive. Finally, as to the claim made under the Consumer Fraud Act, it was argued that it fails because she has not alleged any deceptive or fraudulent conduct by NETS. Following oral argument, the court granted NETS motion, dismissing any and all claims against it with prejudice.
Legal Update for Premises & Retail Liability
New Jersey Supreme Court Strengthens the Ongoing Storm Rule in Gallardo v. Walmart
August 24, 2026
The New Jersey Supreme Court recently expanded the protection afforded by the ongoing storm rule, under which commercial property owners generally have no duty to remove snow or ice while precipitation is actively falling absent unusual circumstances or a preexisting hazardous condition. In Gallardo v. Walmart, No. A-65-24 (N.J. July 30, 2026), the court significantly narrowed a common avenue plaintiffs have used to avoid summary judgment, holding that “ordinary efforts” to address winter conditions during an ongoing storm do not become actionable merely because an expert later claims those efforts made the conditions more dangerous. The case arose from a typical winter slip and fall. Mixed precipitation began around 11:30 a.m. Walmart's snow-removal contractor arrived about an hour later and salted the parking lot and walkways. Because accumulation was minimal, ranging from trace to 1/10th of an inch, the contractor did not plow. The plaintiff fell approximately 15 minutes after the salting was completed. The plaintiff did not contend that Walmart failed to respond to the storm. Instead, she argued that Walmart responded improperly. Her expert opined that salting without pretreating the lot caused melting and refreezing that resulted in black ice. That theory survived two summary judgment motions and ultimately persuaded a jury, which returned a verdict of approximately $1.33 million. The Appellate Division vacated the verdict because the jury had not been properly instructed on the ongoing storm rule, but remanded the matter for a new trial. The New Jersey Supreme Court reversed in a 4-3 decision and directed entry of summary judgment for Walmart. Applying Pareja v. Princeton International Properties, 246 N.J. 546 (2021), the Court concluded that Walmart's conduct fell within the protections of the ongoing storm rule. Salting a trace accumulation during an active storm was ordinary remediation, not the type of unusual circumstance that could give rise to a duty. The court further held that expert criticism of those efforts was insufficient to change that result. Following Pareja, plaintiffs frequently argued that a property owner forfeited the protection of the ongoing storm rule whenever an expert could identify some alleged flaw in the owner's response to the storm. Gallardo rejects that premise. The decision recognizes that imposing liability based solely on expert criticism of ordinary snow removal efforts would discourage property owners from taking any action during a storm and would undermine the very purpose of the doctrine. The ruling warrants a fresh look at pending winter premises liability cases involving active precipitation, minimal accumulations, mid-storm salting, alleged failures to pretreat, or expert opinions premised on melting-and-refreezing theories. Cases previously viewed as presenting substantial trial exposure may now be stronger candidates for summary judgment. At the same time, Gallardo does not eliminate all potential liability during an ongoing storm. A preexisting hazardous condition or genuinely unusual affirmative conduct may still support the imposition of a duty. Plaintiffs will also likely attempt to distinguish Gallardo based on the nature of the remediation efforts at issue and the specific facts of a case. The bottom line is that Gallardo strengthens the ongoing storm rule by restoring it as a meaningful summary judgment defense. Now, “ordinary” efforts to address winter conditions during an active storm do not become "unusual circumstances" simply because a plaintiff retains an expert to say they could have been done differently
Results
News
Marshall Dennehey Named a 2027 Best Law Firm in Multiple Practice Areas by Best Lawyers®
November 5, 2026

Marshall Dennehey Announces 2027 New Jersey Super Lawyers And Rising Stars
October 1, 2026

106 Marshall Dennehey Attorneys Recognized in the 2027 Editions of The Best Lawyers in America® and the Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch® in America
August 20, 2026