.

Defense Digest

Failure to Join Both Property Owners Leads to Case Dismissal*

Defense Digest, Vol. 29, No. 4, December 2023

December 1, 2023

by Brad E. Haas

*This case has since been reversed on appeal. Please see: How Simone V. Alam Reshaped the Standard for Indispensable Parties in Premises Liability Actions

Key Points:

  • Pennsylvania Superior Court recently held that a plaintiff’s failure to join an indispensable party property co-owner was grounds for full dismissal of his premises liability claim.
  • The case discussed the specifics of proprietary rights and ownership, as two brothers co-owned a property as tenants in common.
  • Plaintiff only named one of the co-owner brothers as a defendant, despite being made aware of the joint ownership.
  • The court held that, under Pennsylvania law, because the claim directly related to the ownership and alleged negligence related to that ownership, both of the owners/brothers were indispensable parties to the matter.
  • Due to the fact that the statute of limitations had passed, the court dismissed the action.

A recent decision by the Pennsylvania Superior Court underscores the importance of having a full understanding of the proprietary rights and ownership of a given property in premises liability suits. In Simone v. Alam, 303 A.3d 140 (Pa. Super. 2023), the Superior Court affirmed a trial court’s granting of a motion to dismiss based upon the plaintiff’s failure to join the co-owner of a property.

The lawsuit stemmed from a fall-down incident at a rental property which was owned and maintained by the defendant, Mohammed Zakiul Alam, and his brother, Mohammed Zafuil Alam. The incident occurred on January 16, 2018. The plaintiff filed her complaint on December 2, 2019, alleging the fall occurred due to an accumulation of ice beneath an outdoor staircase. The complaint named Mohammed Zakuil Alam as the only defendant, and not his brother/co-owner. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant owned, possessed, and controlled the property, such that he was responsible for the defective condition that led to her injuries.

The parties engaged in discovery, including responses to interrogatories and party depositions. Through the responses and the defendant’s deposition, it was made clear that the property was co-owned by the two Alam brothers as tenants in common. Despite this, the plaintiff never sought to amend her complaint.

Following the running of the applicable statute of limitations, on October 7, 2020, the defendant filed a Motion to Dismiss for Plaintiff’s Failure to Join an Indispensable Party. The plaintiff argued that the co-owner’s absence should not impact the case, emphasizing that he had no possession or control over the multi-tenant rental property. However, the trial court granted the defendant’s motion, holding that the unnamed co-owner/brother was an indispensable party. The plaintiff thereafter appealed to the Pennsylvania Superior Court. The question before the Superior Court was: Did the trial court err in dismissing her complaint for failure to join an indispensable party when the absent co-owner merely held a tenant-in-common interest without any possession or control over the property?

The plaintiff contended that the co-owners/brothers were merely tenants in common and that the co-owners’ interest would remain unaffected by a judgment against the unnamed defendant Alam. Additionally, she attempted to argue that there was no specific Pennsylvania case law deeming tenants in common as indispensable parties without exceptions. To support her position, she referenced case law from Washington, which provided that a premises liability action could proceed against the possessor of the premises, irrespective of the absence of the true owner.

The Pennsylvania Superior Court disagreed. The court began its opinion by giving an overview of the relevant proprietary rights involved. In discussing tenancy in common, the court noted that when individuals own property as tenants in common, they own and possess, in equal shares, an undivided interest in the whole property. Regarding those rights as it related to indispensability, the court stated that the legal concept of indispensability is defined by the connection between a party’s rights and the claims of the litigants. It further stated that the rule is not based on administrative convenience, but on the unity and identity of co-owners’ interests. The court discussed the case of Northern Forests II, Inc. v. Keta Realty Co., 130 A.3d 19, 29 (Pa. Super. 2015), emphasizing that a party is indispensable when that party’s rights are so connected with the claims that no decree can be made without impairing those rights. The court further noted that Pa.R.C.P. 2227 explicitly states that persons with a joint interest must be joined on the same side as plaintiffs or defendants. 

The court disagreed with the plaintiff’s assertion that there was no on-point Pennsylvania case law, referencing the case of Minner v. Pittsburgh, 69 A.2d 384 (Pa. 1949). In Minner, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court mandated the joinder of all tenants in common in a negligence action arising from ownership of real estate. The Minner mandate was reinforced in the subsequent cases of Moorehead v. Lopatin, 445 A.2d 1308 (Pa. Super. 1982) and Enright v. Kirkendall, 819 A.2d 555 (Pa. Super. 2003). These decisions emphasized that when a party’s liability stems from ownership of real estate held by tenants in common, all co-owners are required to be joined.

The plaintiff’s case, akin to Minner, involved a liability claim arising directly from the unnamed defendant Alam’s ownership of the premises and allegations of negligence based upon that ownership. The Superior Court held that the fact that the Alam brothers were joint owners as tenants in common rendered the co-owner/brother an indispensable party. Based upon this, it affirmed the decision of the trial court, dismissing the plaintiff’s claim.

*Brad is a shareholder in our Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, office. He can be reached at 412.803.2448 or BEHaas@mdwcg.com.


 

Defense Digest, Vol. 29, No. 4, December 2023, is prepared by Marshall Dennehey to provide information on recent legal developments of interest to our readers. This publication is not intended to provide legal advice for a specific situation or to create an attorney-client relationship. ATTORNEY ADVERTISING pursuant to New York RPC 7.1. © 2023 Marshall Dennehey. All Rights Reserved. This article may not be reprinted without the express written permission of our firm. For reprints, contact tamontemuro@mdwcg.com.

 

*This case has since been reversed on appeal. Please see: How Simone V. Alam Reshaped the Standard for Indispensable Parties in Premises Liability Actions

 

Firm Highlights

Thought Leadership

U.S. Department of Education Reports to Congress on Disciplinary Removals of Children with Disabilities

In June 2026, the United States Department of Education, through the Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services (OSERS), published its “47th Annual Report to Congress on the Implementation of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, 2025.” In its report, OSERS provided detailed data and information on the discipline and removal of students from their educational placements, specifically for the school year 2022-2023. To obtain this data, all 50 states, the District of Columbia, the Bureau of Indian Education, Puerto Rico, and other U.S. territories, were asked to report on pre-school and school-aged students, ages 3-21, who were served under IDEA, Part B, and removed from their educational placements for disciplinary reasons during the school year in question. Not all jurisdictions had data available; OSERS’ reporting to Congress was based on the information supplied by the jurisdictions that responded.  First, OSERS examined the total number of served students who were removed to an interim alternative educational setting. From the reporting data, this number totaled 7,204,199 students. Of this total, 11,364 students were removed unilaterally by school personnel for drugs, weapons, or serious bodily injury to themselves or others. These figures reflected the unilateral removal of served students at a rate of 16 per 10,000 students. Of this total, 545 students were removed by a due process hearing officer for likely serious bodily injury, a rate of one per 10,000 students.  Next, OSERS examined data for students who were suspended (in school and out of school) or expelled for more than 10 school days. The total number of students in this category was 7,623,095. Of this total, 65,104 students received out of school suspensions or expulsions, a rate of 85 per 10,000 students. A total of 21,878 students received in school suspensions, a rate of 29 students per 10,000.  OSERS evaluated this particular data and drilled down further, examining the rate of interim removal, expulsion, and suspension per 10,000 students based specifically upon each IDEA disability category. Perhaps not surprisingly, children primarily identified with emotional disturbance were the most affected.    For every 10,000 students who were identified under the category of emotional disturbance, 65 were unilaterally removed to an interim alternative educational setting by school personnel (not the IEP team) for drugs, weapons, or serious bodily injury, and four out of every 10,000 students were removed following a hearing officer finding that there was a substantial likelihood of serious bodily injury to the student or others. By contrast, the ratio of students under each of the other disability categories who were unilaterally removed by school personnel was 25 or less per 10,000 students in each category. No more than two students per 10,000 in each of the other categories were removed by a hearing officer. Other Health Impairment was the second leading category.  For every 10,000 students identified primarily with emotional disturbance, 411 students received out of school suspensions or expulsions of more than 10 days, and 107 of every 10,000 students in this category received in-school suspensions. In comparison, the ratio of students under each of the other disability categories who received out of school suspensions or expulsions of more than 10 days was no more than 172 per 10,000. Students identified in all other disability categories received in-school suspensions at a rate of no more than 57 per 10,000 students. Again, Other Health Impairment was the second leading category. OSERS then examined discipline data with a state-by-state comparison, once more at a ratio of 10,000 students served. The overall data of students who were unilaterally removed to an interim alternative educational setting by school personnel for drugs, weapons, or serious bodily injury showed that removal occurred most frequently in Texas (92 per 10,000 students), Montana (62 per 10,000 students), and Tennessee (42 per 10,000 students). The mean was 12.1.  In Pennsylvania, the rate of removal was 12 out of every 10,000 students, just below the mean.  OSERS also considered, on a state-by-state basis, the number of students who received out-of-school suspensions or expulsions of greater than 10 days. The most significant rate of discipline here occurred in North Carolina (256 per 10,000 students), Missouri (250 per 10,000 students), and South Carolina (250 per 10,000 students).  The mean was 85.83. In Pennsylvania, the rate of discipline was 57 per 10,000 students, well below the mean.  Finally, OSERS evaluated, on a state-by-state comparison, the ratio of students per 10,000 who were identified under the category of emotional disturbance and who received out of school suspensions or expulsions for greater than 10 days. The suspension or expulsion of students with emotional disturbance occurred most often in North Carolina (1,723 per 10,000 students), Missouri (1,127 per 10,000 students), and South Carolina (1,098 per 10,000). The mean was 485.81. In Pennsylvania, the suspension or expulsion of students identified with emotional disturbance occurred at a rate of 260 per 10,000, again well below the mean. Although OSERS did not draw any specific conclusions about the disciplinary data it collected, it is nonetheless evident that students primarily identified with emotional disturbance were removed from their educational placements for disciplinary reasons at a rate much higher than students in any other disability category. Relatively speaking, however, Pennsylvania acquitted itself well in the state-by-state disciplinary data collection.

Thought Leadership

Pennsylvania HB 2307: Special Education Contingency Fund Reform

Pennsylvania school districts and school law attorneys are aware of the increasing cost of special education services. In an effort to address this growing squeeze on school district budgets, a bi-partisan group of Pennsylvania House Representatives introduced House Bill 2307. The bill is a special education funding measure intended to reform Pennsylvania's reimbursement system for extraordinarily high-cost special education students. As written, HB 2307 would increase funding dedicated to Pennsylvania's Extraordinary Special Education Program Expenses reimbursement program. Beginning with the 2026-27 school year, the bill would increase the set-aside from 1% to 2% of the annual Special Education appropriation. The increased funding is aimed at assisting school districts and charter schools address the costs of serving students whose needs generate exceptionally high special education expenses. The proposal specifically targets situations involving students whose annual special education costs exceed the state's highest cost threshold and represent a significant burden on a district's special education budget. HB 2307 includes key eligibility requirements such as: 1) extraordinary special education expenses approved by the Secretary of Education; 2) student costs exceeding the state's highest Category 3A threshold; 3) costs representing at least 1% of the district's total special education expenditures; 4) student enrolled in the district for no more than two consecutive school years for the proposed reimbursement category; and 5) application and documentation requirements for districts and charter schools. HB 2307 successfully passed the Pennsylvania House of Representatives on June 16, 2026, by a unanimous vote of 202-0. It was subsequently transmitted to the Senate and was referred to the Senate Education Committee on June 22, 2026, where it currently remains pending. While there is currently no scheduled Senate committee or floor vote publicly listed for HB 2307, the next step would be for the Senate Education Committee to consider the bill and determine whether to report it to the full Senate for consideration. If approved by the committee, the bill would proceed through the Senate's three-consideration process before a final vote. Because the General Assembly is still within the 2025-26 legislative session, the bill remains eligible for action during the remainder of the session. However, absent committee action, it will not become law before the start of the 2026-27 school year. If enacted, HB 2307 could have several important effects: Greater financial stability for districts serving students with exceptionally expensive educational and related-service needs. Increased reimbursement opportunities for high-cost placements, specialized transportation, intensive behavioral supports, and other extraordinary services. Reduced pressure on local special education budgets, particularly in smaller districts where one or two high-cost students can significantly affect annual expenditures. Potential reduction in litigation and placement disputes driven by financial constraints, although the bill does not alter substantive IDEA rights or district obligations to provide FAPE.