Caitlin A. Polly


Caitlin is a member of the Professional Liability Department. She focuses her practice on first-party insurance coverage, defending insurance carriers in a wide range of first-party property matters and assists insurers with disputes pertaining to coverage and bad faith matters.

Prior to joining Marshall Dennehey, Caitlin worked at a local firm where she handled first party property claims, breach of contract, and bad faith matters.

Caitlin graduated from Florida State University in 2010 with a degree in Social Science. Caitlin received her juris doctor from Florida Coastal School of Law in 2017. During law school, Caitlin was the recipient of a Merit Scholarship, the Martha Sonnenschein Memorial Scholarship for outstanding law school leadership in addition to classroom performance, and a CALI Excellence for the Future Award in Legal Writing. She served as both Managing Editor and Staff Editor of the Florida Coastal Law Review, served as an Advocate for the Mock Trial team, served as Vice Director for the Student Ambassador program, served as a legislator for the Student Bar Association, served on the Honor Council, and additionally served as a Student Member on several Jacksonville Bar Association [Young Lawyer Division] committees.

Published Works

“AOB No Longer A-OK,” Defense Digest, Vol. 25, No. 3, September 2019

"FAWL's Pursuit of Courthouse Balance; Litigation and Lactation Rooms in the Sunshine State," FAWL Journal, Operation Gender Equality, Fall/Winter 2018 Co-Author

"Everything Lienors Need to Know About Construction Releases in Florida," September 16, 2016

"Effective Use of Demonstrative Evidence in Commercial Litigation," May 13, 2016

Florida Coastal School of Law (J.D., 2017)
Florida State University (B.S., 2010)
Associations & memberships
American Bar Association
E. Robert Williams Inn of Court
Florida Association of Women Lawyers - Lactation Committee
Florida Bar Association, Young Lawyers Division
Jacksonville Women Lawyers Association
St. Johns Association of Women Lawyers
St. John's County Bar Association
Year joined