Wengert v. Phoebe Ministries, 2012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 151236 (E.D. Pa. Oct. 22, 2012)

An employee's failure to provide evidence that the decision maker was aware of his disability mandates dismissal of his claim.

The plaintiff and another employee were terminated following an incident where a resident fell and was injured and the subsequent investigation by the employer revealed that proper procedures were not utilized by the employees. Following the plaintiff's termination, he filed a lawsuit, alleging that his termination was due to the fact that he is HIV-positive. In particular, the plaintiff asserted that there was a prior incident in which a patient bit him, which required a co-worker to take blood to determine if he contracted HIV. The plaintiff, however, informed the co-worker that he was already HIV-positive. The plaintiff's co-worker later took a statement from a witness in connection with the incident that resulted in the plaintiff's termination. In rejecting the plaintiff's claim, the court expressly noted that a plaintiff must demonstrate that the employer was aware of his disability in order to sustain a disability discrimination claim and that, in this case, the decision maker testified she was not aware of the plaintiff's HIV-status.

Case Law Alert - 1st Quarter 2013